They put him in the back seat of the Impala and drove away from the motel, Parker at the wheel and Grofield occasionally glancing back at Abadandi. After several blocks, Grofield said, in a troubled and unhappy way “Goddamnit.”
“What’s the matter?”
“Now he’s bleeding from the ear.”
“Put some paper on it.”
Grofield opened the glove compartment. “Nothing there.”
“Turn his head then. We’ll unload him in a couple minutes.”
Grofield adjusted Abadandi’s head. Parker drove away from the city, looking for a turnoff that might lead to privacy. They were going to be late to Lozini’s, but there wasn’t any help for it. Sunday morning traffic was light and mostly slow-moving; family groups.
“I feel sorry for the bastard,” Grofield said.
Parker glanced at him and looked back at the road. “If I’d slept late this morning,” he said, “he could be feeling sorry for you by now.”
“An hour ago I was getting laid back there,” Grofield said. “Jesus, his skin looks bad.”
Parker kept driving.
There’s no such thing as a Butcher’s Moon. It’s something Westlake made up himself, responding to the old tradition of naming the full moons for each specific time of year–it’s something the first Americans started here, and the European settlers emulated and added to, but the idea seems to have occurred independently in many cultures. Many variations exist. There’s a Harvest Moon, a Hunter’s Moon–and a Wolf Moon (that’s in the dead of winter). But none of these are a Butcher’s Moon. Because a Butcher’s Moon is no moon at all. Some things are best done in darkness.
I might as well mention here that somebody optioned this novel for a film version in 1996. Variety reported at the time that Lumiere Films, which produced Leaving Las Vegas, had shelled out for the rights, attached Steve Shagan, the screenwriter for Primal Fear to write the screenplay, and that same film’s producer, Gary Lucchesi, to produce it (the film had not come out yet). Lumiere CEO Randolph Pitts (it’s wrong to make fun of people’s names) said Butcher’s Moon was ‘one of Westlake’s grittiest efforts.’
“Lila Cazes, who’s head of production, and myself are developing a number of things with Gary and he suggested this book, which Westlake did under the pseudonym he used to write his hardest-hitting crime books,” said Pitts. “Then, Gary suggested we meet with Steve Shagan after they’d done Primal Fear.”
We are further informed that Westlake (who is not quoted in Variety, because hey, he’s just the novelist), was repped by Gary Salt of Paul Kohner Agency. And nothing more was ever heard of this film, nor shall be in all the eons to come.
Could be any number of reasons for that, but I’d certainly suspect one of them was that it’s one of the worst possible choices for a film adaptation (the worst possible choice probably being Flashfire). It’s the least self-contained of the Parker novels, the one where the reader depends most on his or her memories of the books before it. Now I would not say you couldn’t enjoy reading it if you’d never read a Parker novel before–but I can’t imagine how anyone doing so wouldn’t feel like dropping everything to find all those earlier books, and fill in all the gaps in his or her knowledge of that fictional world and its hard-boiled denizens. That may be one of the reasons Westlake wrote it that way, but I don’t think it’s the only one.
I wonder if Shagan ever completed any drafts of a screenplay? A treatment, at least? I’d be interested to see what he did with it–how he tried to somehow collapse the plot into a film-able unit without having any previous films to refer back to. He was a novelist himself (he wrote Save The Tiger, and then adapted it into the Jack Lemmon movie that I have yet to see). He wrote the screenplays for a number of well known films, such as Voyage of the Damned, and he did some mafia stuff, and no, I don’t think it would have worked. And if they’d stuck to the original ending, I bet film buffs would have accused them of ripping off The Outfit. Which might not have been totally out of line. But let’s get back to the synopsis.
We pick up with Mike Abadandi, one of Lozini’s trigger men in the mobbed up city of Tyler–we met him in Slayground, and the late Mr. Caliato, when he saw Abadandi was going to be helping him go after Parker at Fun Island, evaluated him with one word–“Good.” He’s a very capable individual, probably the best hitter Lozini’s outfit has at the moment. And he’s been sent to whack Parker and Grofield at their motel.
Why send one guy after two? Because whoever wants this done wants it done quietly and professionally, with as little fuss and mess as possible. And because Lozini doesn’t know anything about it. This is not a properly sanctioned hit. Meaning that the more guys they use, the more chance there is Lozini will find out before they want him to.
He uses a set of skeleton keys, and lets himself into the motel room, after he sees Grofield go in there, back from his highly athletic extramarital rendezvous with Dori the librarian. We can sense his professionalism–he’s somebody Parker would be happy to work with, if he wasn’t an organization man. Grofield is in the shower, singing (tunelessly, we’re told, so I guess he doesn’t do musicals). Abadandi figures he’ll get Grofield, then look for Parker. Bird in the hand.
But the other bird is in the closet–Parker saw Abadandi lurking around from his room, and set a trap for him. Abadandi realizes Parker is coming at him, and is looking at his eyes, not the gun in his hand (which is pointed the wrong way), and he has just enough time to realize he’s up against somebody as good as him. Maybe better, Mike.
What follows is a short violent struggle, and one of the few instances in twenty-four books that we see Parker have a prolonged physical altercation with a worthy opponent–he’s not the type to engage in pointless fisticuffs. Abadandi doesn’t panic, he gives a good account of himself, but Parker is always a move ahead. Abadandi, who is wearing contacts, gets a hard kick to the head, then as he falls, Parker chops him in the neck with a huge veiny hand, and that’s the last we hear from Abadandi.
Parker hadn’t intended to injure the guy that badly–wanted to get some info out of him first (otherwise he’d have just shot him). But one of the contacts has gone into his brain or something (I don’t know if this is a real thing, and I don’t want to know). He’s not talking to anybody, probably ever. But a look through his pockets clearly shows his affiliations, and Parker and Grofield already have a meet scheduled with Lozini at his house.
Parker and Grofield (who is using the name Green, in a little nod to his alternate universe doppelganger in the Dortmunder novels) show up there, and give Lozini the bad news. And it’s really bad. The only way Abadandi could have found their motel is if they were followed from the last meeting they had with him and his closest associates, at the office. Only his most highly placed people knew about that meeting. At least one of them made sure there was somebody waiting outside the office building. Parker can make a very cogent persuasive argument when he wants to–and his argument now is that Lozini can only trust two people in the entire city.
“You’ve got a palace takeover on your hands,” Parker told him. “That means a group, maybe four or five, maybe a dozen A group of people inside your organization that want you out and somebody else in. Somebody who’s already up close to the top, that they want to take your place.”
Lozini took his sunglasses off and massaged his closed eyes with thumb and forefinger. His eyes still closed, he said “For the first time in my life I know what getting old is. It’s wanting to be able to call for a time-out.” He put the sunglasses back on and studied them both. Their faces were closed to him, and always would be. “You’re right,” he said. “You’re the only ones I can trust, because I know exactly where you stand and what you want.”
They discuss the possible suspects, eliminating them one by one–it comes down to Ernie Dulare, who controls offtrack gambling, and Louis ‘Dutch’ Buenadella, who runs the local porno theaters. Lozini is surprised how much they already know, courtesy of Grofield’s research. But they all missed a very big important detail, that comes out when Parker asks if Farrell, the mob’s candidate for mayor, would be in on it. Lozini is bewildered–his candidate is Alfred Wain. Farrell is the reform candidate they’re trying to beat. And now Parker begins to see he’s badly misjudged the situation in Tyler.
Coming into town, Parker saw that Farrell had a lot more money behind him, more signs, bigger banners, and figured that meant he was the syndicate’s man–and that he is, but the new syndicate, not the old one. They were, in fact, using some of Parker and Grofield’s money to finance him, as well as Lozini’s. That’s part of the take-over. With their man in place at city hall, they can push Lozini out, and there won’t even be a fight. Lozini never even saw it coming–until Parker pointed it out to him. But Parker is angry at himself for not seeing it sooner. False premises. Hasty assumptions. They’ll get you every time. You have to know the territory.
Is it a bit much, making Parker smarter about politics than Lozini, who has been controlling this city for decades, or even Grofield, who spent hours researching Tyler’s political scene, and has shown some knowledge of politics in past? Should a wolf in human form really know so much about the way our power structures work? Technically, wolves are all about politics–who has the power in the pack at a given moment–it’s a lot more complicated than people think. It’s not just Alphas and Omegas. Nobody knows better than a wolf how transitory power can be, how quickly it can change allegiance.
Watch two dogs smelling each other, sizing each other up, sensing subtle changes that we’re entirely oblivious to. They know far more about us than we about them–always watching us, even when they seem not to be. We are, after all, their source of sustenance. But see, dogs give a damn about us. Parker doesn’t.
Basically, Parker knows what he needs to know about us to survive in our world. He’s always evaluating the situation, the battlefields he makes his living upon, which happen to be our communities, because that’s where the money is. His mind functions more efficiently without all the distractions that plague the rest of us–but he can still make mistakes. He’s been too focused on what he wants (the money), and hadn’t given enough thought to what others might be wanting. And now he’s off-balance, wrong-footed. He’s got a new enemy, whose name he doesn’t even know. He’s got to fix that, and quickly.
Next chapter is from the perspective of George Farrell, local furniture magnate, pillar of the community, who has become bored with the family business, and consequently developed a taste for politics (tell me if you’ve heard this one before). To further this end, he’s made a deal with known criminals–they’ll get him into power, and he’ll do their bidding, but he figures once he has the power, he can handle them just fine. What he can’t handle is two guys pretending to be his new security detail, who turn out to be Parker and Grofield. His self-assurance cracks quickly under the weight of Parker’s fists. He blurts out the name of his patron–Louis Buenadella.
And now we’re with Harold Calesian, detective first grade on Tyler’s police force, and a trusted member of Lozini’s inner circle–he’s in with Buenadella, of course. Having picked a side, he intends to do all he can to make sure everything works out as planned, and to that end, he’s the one who murdered Officer O’Hara, who knew too much about what happened that night at the amusement park, two years ago. He’s just back from murdering Paul Dunstan, the other cop there that night, who tried (too late) to get clean, get away, get free. There was about one chance in a million that Dunstan would ever have been a problem for Calesian. One chance too many. Some people really do make murder the answer to everything.
He gets to his apartment, and Lozini is there waiting for him. Lozini knows whoever is behind the coup wouldn’t have made a move without getting their top cop on his side. He wants Calesian to tell him who it is. If Calesian won’t tell him, Lozini will start shooting him in various non-fatal areas of his anatomy. Lozini is done fooling around.
Lozini’s arc in this book is interesting–he’s become aware, very suddenly, of how much he’s allowed himself to slip–too many years of playing the part of respectable citizen–over time, you become the person you pretend to be. The old gangster has lost his edge. This is the first time in decades he’s even held a gun in his hand. But he’s still dangerous.
Lozini doesn’t like to be pushed, but he doesn’t really want a fight either. This is his identity crisis. He’s trapped between two versions of himself–the ruthless man he used to be, and the easy-going amateur chef who pulls the strings from a safe distance, and has long avoided any direct use of violence, because it didn’t make sense for a man in his position to take that kind of risk. That man he used to be is still down there inside of him–as was the case with Bronson, when Parker came for him, years before–but the reflexes have dulled. Memory isn’t enough.
He tells Calesian he’s just about ready to retire, leave town, play shuffleboard. But he can’t accept being forced out by an underling. He wants to make some kind of deal, come to an arrangement. This is his mistake. This is why he’s about to die. Because you can’t have it both ways. You can’t have absolute power, and then just bargain it away at your convenience. In this kind of business, you’re all the way in, or all the way out. Kings don’t get to retire. A fellow named Lear could have told him that. Different mob.
Calesian is finished if he tells Lozini he’s working for Buenadella, and a cripple if he won’t. So he feeds him a lie, says it’s the other possible, Ernie Dulare. That gets Lozini off balance, thinking about something other than Calesian, who says he’s got something in his bag that will prove he’s telling the truth–what he’s got is the same gun he used to kill Dunstan. Lozini takes just a second too long figuring out what’s happening. Well, he probably wouldn’t have enjoyed shuffleboard much, anyway. Stupid game.
So next we’re with Buenadella the porn merchant, get a bit of his background–he’s the new style of ganglord. All business. We’ve seen this dichotomy before in Westlake’s work (361, The Outfit, etc). When gangsters start going legit, they stop being gangsters. Difference is, Buenadella, who got his start in the mafia, never really was a gangster at heart. The coup he’s planned is supposed to be bloodless. He’s not out to whack anybody. He really thought that could work. Then Farrell tells him about Parker and Grofield–who suddenly show up at his house, armed. So much for that plan.
Grofield can’t believe how tacky the house is–like a bad stage set. It’s reminiscent of how Westlake described Vigano’s house in Cops and Robbers. Too many clashing elements, the elegant alongside the vulgar, indicative of nouveau riche tastes. But he’s got to focus on what’s happening–Parker is tired of the run-around. He wants their 73 grand, and Buenadella, since he now wants to be the man in charge, is going to cough it up or die.
Thing is, Buenadella spent a lot of that money from the amusement park on this coup of his. He didn’t need it to pull the coup off successfully, it was just a convenient piece of extra capital he didn’t want Lozini to get his hands on. He wishes he’d never seen the money, but hindsight won’t stop Parker from killing him if he can’t pay. Money is very tight in his organization at the moment because it’s supporting not one but two mayoral campaigns–but he figures he can manage to come up with the cash before the election, somehow. Just to make these two very frightening individuals go their merry way.
Grofield is privately a bit critical of Parker’s negotiating skills here (if you want to call them that)–he’s thinking you can’t push so hard, or they push back. He’s dealt with businessmen before, in his acting life. Let Buenadella come around, see the sense of their proposal. Between the good and bad cop approach, they get Buenadella to at least tentatively agree to give them what they want. And as he and Parker are walking out the rear-facing french doors they’d come in through, Grofield gets shot in the chest by a guy he barely glimpses, who was waiting outside.
It spun him around. Everything went out of focus as he turned, like a special effect in a movie. He killed me! Grofield thought despairingly, and slid down the invisible glass wall of life.
That’s a death scene, if ever there was one. Any other Richard Stark character, that’d be the last POV chapter he ever got. The language is not at all ambiguous, but (spoiler alert) Grofield does not die. So what’s up with that?
Up to this point, you could say this was as much a Grofield novel as a Parker–the conclusion to both sagas–Grofield has been co-protagonist, and in this chapter, he’s even seeming to take control of the partnership for a moment. In his mind, as has been the case since we first met him, he’s the hero, dramatic music playing in the background as he goes through his paces, rescues the maiden, defeats the bad guys (even though he’s technically a bad guy). That’s how it plays out in his mind.
But not in Stark’s mind. That’s the problem–Stark has always preferred Parker–Parker belongs in the world of Richard Stark–Grofield, as I’ve said before, is a Westlake character who wandered into Stark’s realm by mistake, and perhaps outstayed his welcome.
Grofield is respected, by Parker and by Stark, for his skills, his professionalism, his refusal to compromise his craft by working in television and film–but his entire life is a compromise. Is he an actor or a robber? A devoted husband or a footloose philanderer? One foot in sea and one on shore, to one thing constant never. Which is what an actor needs to be, which is why an actor wrote that line.
I think Westlake, the former spear-carrier in summer theater, always had a soft spot for him–he represents some old fantasies, and is certainly based in part on Westlake’s first-ever series protagonist, the lusty young journeyman actor, Phil Crawford, who appeared in several of Westlake’s sleaze novels (only one of which I’ve read).
But in Stark’s world, Grofield’s been living on borrowed time. He’s always on the brink of dying, in the Parker novels and his own, only to escape the final reckoning by the skin of his proverbial teeth. Now the bill has come due. He’s being rejected by that world, cast forth from it. Westlake may not intend this, but Stark does, and in a Parker novel, Stark has the final word.
And even though Grofield is clearly referring to the man he saw shoot him when he says “He killed me”, he’s always seemed to me to have just an inkling of the fact that he’s a player on a larger stage, and maybe he knows on some level who really pulled the trigger on him just now. Any actor knows, when the playwright says you’re dead, you have to lie down–but as Raoul Walsh once wryly quipped, when asked why James Cagney’s bullet-riddled character takes forever to die at the end of The Roaring 20’s, “It’s hard to kill an actor.”
This is all getting rather meta, I know, but the most Westlake, Vishnu to Stark’s Shiva, can do for Grofield is intercede quietly on his creation’s behalf, try to soften the blow. And there’s only one ‘hero’ in this myth-cycle who can do that for him–Parker.
But Parker’s reaction, as he flees out the front door of Buenadella’s house, protected by the presence of a surveillance van manned by state police, is merely It was too bad about Grofield. Soldiers die in wars all the time. He’s got no intention of doing anything about it. His objective at this point is still just the money. 73 grand would tide him and Claire over for some time. For him to think about anything else, someone’s going to have to push that button in his head that makes him need to kill whoever pushed it.
Grofield’s shooter was Calesian, who had come to Buenadella’s to tell him about Lozini, saw the car, and realized what was happening–then realized too late that both Parker and Grofield were there, so he didn’t wait for them both to come into view as he lay in wait. So Parker got away, and now he’s got to deal with a raging Buenadella, who is angry enough that a situation he was about to resolve non-violently has just been escalated. He’s even more upset when he finds out Lozini is dead. Killing a boss is a serious business–there’s people at the national level who will be angered by it, since they’re bosses too.
But Buenadella’s power, so newly achieved, is already falling away from him–his business as usual approach doesn’t fit the situation, and it’s not like he’s been elected to anything–he’s only boss if people do what he says. Calesian begins to realize he can be boss now–he’s the one who took charge when things got tough. So in spite of his seeming lowly status in the organization, he can take control of the whole shooting match now if he wants, and much to his surprise, he really really wants that. A cop could be the boss of the local mafia. Gee, no identity crisis there, right?
But this means he has to pin Lozini’s death on somebody else. Parker will do nicely as the fall guy. Buenadella fearfully agrees, not knowing how to do anything else. He’ll make a good figurehead. Calesian is making all the plans, and the other powers in the Tyler mob fall in behind him–and accept his story that Parker shot Lozini without question–that will also be the story they tell the national syndicate leaders, like Karns. But that means they can’t cut a deal with Parker anymore. They have to kill him to shut him up. Which means they have to lure him in somehow. Calesian knows just the way–and here comes the one scene people most remember in the book.
A meet is arranged over the phone–Parker makes very sure the emissary wasn’t being tailed. Ted Shevelly, Lozini’s loyal consigliere (he was never even approached about the coup), who doesn’t know what’s really going on here, is delegated to bring Parker a token of their regard. One of Grofield’s little fingers in a little white box. To prove he’s still alive. They’ll keep sending more fingers, and other things, until Parker agrees to come in and talk. Then he’ll get his money, and Grofield, and an ambulance to take him away in.
Parker knows there’d be no talking if he took that deal. But that isn’t the point anymore. The button has been pushed. The button nobody in this world can ever un-push. The money has now assumed a secondary importance to him. Or maybe it’s been inextricably mingled together in his mind with something else. Something much older.
And you can imagine that very ancient fire kindling behind his unreadable onyx eyes, his facial expression not altering in the slightest as that thing inside of him is irreversibly triggered, as we have seen happen many times before, but somehow never quite like this. If they had made that movie they planned, can you think of any actor who could have expressed that subtle yet unmistakable transition? Lee Marvin, maybe. Not an option in 1996.
He knows immediately that this isn’t Buenadella’s idea–that Calesian is in charge. He tells Shevelly that. Shevelly doesn’t understand. Shevelly is being very obtuse. Fatally so.
“It was a stupid thing to kill Al Lozini,” Shevelly said.
Parker frowned at him, looking at the coldly angry face. “Oh. They told you I did that, huh?”
Shevelly had nothing to say. Parker, studying him, saw there was no point arguing with him, and no longer possible to make use of him. He gestured with the pistol toward Shevelly, saying, “Get out of the car.”
“Just get out. Leave the door open, back away to the sidewalk, keep facing me.”
Shevelly frowned. “What for?”
“I take precautions. Do it.”
Puzzled Shevelly opened the door and climbed out onto the thin grass next to the curb. He took a step to the sidewalk and turned around to face the car again.
Parker leaned far to the right, aiming the pistol out at arm’s length in front of him, the line of the barrel sighted on Shevelly’s head. Shevelly read his intention and suddenly thrust his hands out protectively in front of himself shouting “I’m only the messenger!”
“Now you’re the message,” Parker told him, and shot him.
Parker spends the next few hours seeking a base of operations–he chooses Calesian’s neighborhood. He’d already looked Calesian up in the phone book, broke into his apartment, found Lozini’s body. He’s not interested in any of that now, he’s just aware of the fact that it’s the kind of impersonal upscale neighborhood where strangers will not be noticed. He picks a large apartment building, uses skeleton keys (Abadandi’s?) to check the apartments that don’t have any mail downstairs. He finds one belonging to a couple who just left on vacation. He moves his and Grofield’s things there. He makes some calls. Some guys take longer than others to find, but he’s very persistent. When he’s finished, eleven of the men he talked to are on their way to Tyler.
Now re-reading this, I was moved to wonder–does he have a little black book of fellow heisters, or their contacts, that he carries around with him? That seems like a potentially dangerous piece of evidence to carry around. Which would mean he’s got all those numbers committed to memory. For just such situations as this. In The Outfit, he used the mail–he sent letters to various heisters he knew, telling them these organization men had violated some unwritten law about leaving their kind alone, and as a result they should feel free to ignore the unwritten law that they don’t hit Outfit businesses, no matter how invitingly soft they look. And surprisingly enough, it worked–they didn’t do it as a favor to him, but they did it, and it helped bring down Arthur Bronson.
There’s no time for that now. And he’s not just out to bring down Buenadella, Calesian, or whoever else happens to be in charge. This is not the same situation–they just owed him money then. Now they owe him blood. The entire organization is responsible for sending him that finger. The entire organization has to pay. Yes, it is rather reminiscent of Anarchaos, isn’t it? But Parker is no neophyte, like Rolf Malone. And Grofield isn’t his brother, not that we can be sure a mere genetic relationship would matter to him. No matter how Parker may or may not feel about his fallen colleague, Grofield’s plight, in and of itself, wouldn’t be enough to make Parker act this way. But the finger was. Why?
Leaving that question to one side for the moment, we now move through a series of chapters from the perspective of some characters from past books we haven’t seen in some time, and at least two we never thought we’d see again. As the moon continues to wane over Tyler, eleven of Parker’s fellow ‘wolves’ (and one lovely little bitch named Brenda, and I only mean that as a compliment) descend upon Tyler, which as we were informed early in the book, never did build a wall around itself, to serve as protection from rapacious bands of brigands, and other beasts of the night. Such things are in the distant past. Not anything a modern American city needs worry about.
The 1927-28 New York Yankees line-up was famously known as ‘Murderer’s Row’, but they got nothing on this all star line-up. Stan Devers and Philly Webb, from the Air Force base job in Monequois. Dan Wycza, Frank Elkins, and Ralph Wiss, from the legendary Copper Canyon heist. Mike Carlow, the ultimate getaway driver, sprung from jail after getting nabbed for his role in the Indianapolis coin convention score–as a neat bonus, we find out that Otto Mainzer, the loud-mouth Nazi rapist they worked with on that one had, with his usual fine-tuned grasp of the social graces, made himself so generally noxious to the law that they were practically begging Carlow to accept a deal in exchange for turning state’s. No prisoner’s dilemma here, since the two loathed each other at first sight, and nobody wanted to give Mainzer a break.
But wait, there’s more! Ed and Brenda Mackey who we met in Plunder Squad, are driving there, everyone’s favorite fun crime couple, exchanging saucy single-entendres, and not in any way discussing the fact that last time we saw Ed, he was supposed to be lying dead in a burning warehouse, after Parker left him there. I’m sure that will be explained very shortly.
Just to remind us how this atypically long Parker novel got started, Ducasse, Dalesia, and the other Hurley (the one Parker and Grofield did not shoot full of holes for ratting on them) are coming as well. Last and the precise opposite of least, there’s Handy McKay, the first and finest of Parker’s partners in crime, out of retirement at last, courtesy of Uncle Sam’s infrastructure upgrades that have made his little diner in Maine unprofitable. With a few pertinent questions to ask of his old comrade.
Murderer’s Row, indeed. Parker’s getting the band back together, except most of these guys don’t even know each other, except through him. You realize what a deep bench of irreformable hard cases he’s compiled in his head over the years. This is the dream team he always aspired to create, but somehow there was always a bad apple, a weak link. Not this time. And just as in Copper Canyon, there’s twelve of them (Grofield makes thirteen), and just as in The Score, you wonder if you’re supposed to be drawing some blasphemous inference or other.
Parker isn’t just calling in the reserves–he’s drawing up battle plans. To that end, he hijacks poor Frankie Faran, who manages that club Parker and Grofield hit a few nights back. Frankie is no great shakes in the Tyler mob, but due to his position–you might say he’s their social director–he’s had many an informal chat over drinks with all the major players, and he knows everything Parker needs to know about all the rackets in town. Which Parker needs to know because Murderer’s Row doesn’t work for nothing. Frankie is terrified of what his friends would do to him if they found out he’d spilled the beans to Parker, but we’ve seen this dance before, and in no time at all, he’s much more terrified of what Parker will do to him if he doesn’t.
In the meantime, the moon over Tyler has shrunk to a mere silver sliver–tomorrow night it’ll be pitch black out, or would be if some joker turned out the lights. In that bit of remaining moonlight, we see Grofield, lying in a bed in Buenadella’s house, hooked up to tubes, breathing shallowly, his hands making the occasional spasmodic movement (Should I mention that this chilling tableau reminds me of the stroke scene in Ex Officio? Probably not). His heart stops. Then starts up again. Hang in there, buddy. You’ve got Vishnu in your corner, and Shiva has bigger fish to fry.
That gets us about 212 pages in, and that’ll do for Part 2. Just ninety-four pages to go. And if you can point out a more perfectly paralyzing pulse-pounding ninety-four pages anywhere else in the annals of fictive crime, I’d be only too grateful. But perhaps a mite skeptical.
So I just have to cough up Part 3 and we’re done. In our dimension (in the Northern Hemisphere), the next Butcher’s Moon will occur this coming Sunday, September 13th. I’m making no promises here, but I’ll see what I can do.
(Part of Friday’s Forgotten Books)
10 responses to “Review: Butcher’s Moon, Part 2”
While BM is not my fave Parker, I’ll admit I shed a tear while reading it. And now, reading this review made me shed another tear.
I like the concept of Grofield being a stranger, an outsider in the Stark universe. Thar raises a question: if Parker acted alone from the start he probably would have avoided all the future trouble and got what was owed to him sooner? Grofield made him more vulnerable. Probably, Parker could even fight alone against the mob, without calling in the whole army. But I guess that was the point of the book, to gather all the heisters to help Parker.
No, I would say Parker chose his ally well, not that he really had a choice, since Grofield had a right to his half of the loot. Grofield is very effective here–just not as effective as Parker, which is no disgrace, since no one is. And Parker doesn’t get his money sooner, as we should all understand, because that would make for a much less interesting story. 😉
Parker gathering all his colleagues would attract movie people, it became some sort of a cliche. It could have become a film – but only as a mediocre one, where Parker could’ve been just faceless robber and killer, avenging hero.
I think it’s just too much story for a film, particularly with all the back-story. They’d have cut it to pieces, and it’s so finely contrived, so carefully put together, that to mess with the plot that much would bring the whole structure crashing down in a heap. But as the climax to a series of TV adaptations, it could work. If it was done right. Which as you know, I greatly doubt it ever would be.
Hollywood has a long tradition of choosing the most unadaptable sources and turning them into utter shit. I think movie people would just cut off all the references, all inside jokes, and would make a shoot-all action film. Anyone for that?
The one thing we can know for sure is that the hero would not have been named Parker. Westlake would not have expected a faithful adaptation, and always said that a movie should be different from the book.
But seriously, you’d need at least a two-part film–like Kill Bill–to do this one properly. You’d get Quentin Tarantino to write/direct it. He’d cast a lot of great semi-forgotten character actors, and a few big stars. There’d have to be a lot of flashbacks, which Tarantino has always excelled at. It would be over the top, larger than life, with long dialogue segments, incorporating Westlake’s dialogue with Tarantino’s additions.
Part 1 would be the set-up, with Parker and Grofield going after the money, establishing the setting, ending with Parker shooting Shevelly. Part 2 would be Parker’s revenge, calling in the crew, and there’d be offscreen narration explaining who all these people are. It’d be great. Just not as great as the book. And it will never happen. Tarantino loves the Stark novels, I’m sure he’s thought about adapting one, but I suspect he just sees the truth–there’s something vital in them that will never translate to film. Anyway, he’s too busy re-inventing the spaghetti western. Whatever.
“A New Parker Novel Of Violence” on that cover is so great.
That’s the UK paperback (there doesn’t seem to have been a hardcover), from Coronet, a division of Hodder and Stoughton. Definitely the best of this week’s bunch. The grotty rustic hunting jackets are a particularly nice touch. Mind you, you could use that same artwork for most other Parker novels, or completely unconnected books about armed robbery, or even a book about IRA terrorists. But that’s nitpicking. 😉
(tunelessly, we’re told, so I guess he doesn’t do musicals).
Maybe Stephen Sondheim.
Couldn’t afford the rights. Be interesting to see what he did with Sweeney Todd, though. Mary would make a fetching Mrs. Lovett. Wouldn’t want to make it a long-running production. Len Cariou ruined his voice playing Sweeney. Sondheim may be a tad atonal, but he’s vocally demanding. I saw the original production with Cariou and Lansbury at the Uris. It was bloody great theater. Accent on bloody. The whole family went. We met Father Germaine, from our New Jersey parish there–great patron of the theater. He loved “A Little Priest.” 😉